To learn more, see our, 3D Coat and Substance Painter are categorized as. Any advice or recommendations are appreciated! Substance Painter rates 4.7/5 stars with 30 reviews. of any help :c. Just to note that SP 2.5 now supports proper layered(built up) opacity painting strokes, and the beginnings of a limited PS bridge. Any way to get that back? Painter is not for painting but for procedural texturing. if it's hard to achieve a nice result, then motivation quickly reaches rock bottom. YES. simple reason : Substance Painter records EVERY stroke you make so 3D Coat rates 4.3/5 stars with 20 reviews. When comparing 3D-Coat vs Substance Painter, the Slant community recommends Substance Painter for most people. Substance Painter is the industry standard for procedural texture painting and the layer system is very powerful, like a 3D version of photoshop. 3d coat is for applying texture to your 3d models. Hi! Hard to say what I like best, there's so much to like! I love 3D Coat and definitely think it has it's place - I find it's actual painting tools are far better than Substance Painter, and on top of that it's good for retopo and UVs. Import your curvature, normal, ao, etc in 3D-Coat and then hand-paint from there. Following that, you can send the paint job over to the editor you picked, save and then it goes right back to 3D Coat with the changes. With your permission, we may also use cookies to share information about your use of our Site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. I know 3D coat is commonly used for Hand Painted texturing, but is Substance Painter also? Substance Painter is more or less good for slapping on substances rather than painting. And you can easily have a "bridged" workflow between 3D-Coat and Photoshop or Krita. That's great. These are all awesome replys. based on data from user reviews. This is a paid texture program. Like UI and navigational treatments, and smart material usage. that the workflow is never destructive. I still think working between PS and 3dcoat is easier than SubPainter/PS and Layer blending modes are more useful in 3dcoat but that might just be my bias. Painter isn't ideal for this sort of work - fundamentally it's a compositing tool so it really only shines when you work with masked  layers. Substance is actually a lot more feature-full than people realize. 3D coat is also known in the game industry to be a great app to preform retopology. Probably the bets feature is the team behind it, constantly adding features at little to no added cost. Substance Painter rates 4.7/5 stars with 29 reviews. You can not export substance (sbsar) files in Painter. lol any coupon codes? necessity to export to Photoshop is antiquated. Substance Painter has smart materials, smart masks and integrated bakers, and a state of the art real-time viewport. Each product's score is calculated by real-time data from verified user reviews. Despite what its name suggest, Substance Painter is not really a tool to paint textures in the "handpainted" sense as it is lacking some of the core features that 3DCoat relies on for this task - amongst others, the ability to send a screenshot of what is currently being worked on to Photoshop in order to paint there then reproject. Why is it in this list? Paint in 3D in real time. i never managed with substance, something very unnatural about it when trying to layer paint and not just doodle on masks, also not very performant in my experience, even on medium density assets. Any way to get that back? In the question“What are the best 3D texture painting softwares?” Substance Painter is ranked 2nd while 3D-Coat is ranked 9th. Agree on avoiding Substance Painter for this kind of work. Would you guys use substance more for PBR and realism and 3D Coat for stylized??? You can texture in many styles with this app, but when it comes to Handpainting, as seen in World of Warcraft and Torchlight, 3D Coat is the one that many professionals will advice you to as their top choice. Voxel is quite heavy on your computer, if you intent to use this as your main model and sculpt app do enough research to see if your computer can handle it and if you have the right graphic card for it. You can save and open your texture work in apps like Photoshop, work on them and send them directly back to 3D coat. One of the reasons it does not have export/import for Photoshop is because the necessity to export to Photoshop is antiquated - Substance painter is basically Photoshop in 3D and for full texture sets (materials). Yeah, the painting in 3D Coat is just so nice. Substance Painter is ranked 2nd while 3D-Coat is ranked 9th. I already used up my trial and didn't use it well. The most important reason people chose Substance Painter is: Since Substance Painter allows users to paint in full 3D, it can be used not only to paint full textures, but can also paint masks which can then be used in other tools (like Substance Designer) for material filter generators (like the ones used to make edge wear and dirt). Tell us what you’re passionate about to get your personalized feed and help others. All image rights belong to their authors. (To export the wireframe, from the Paint tab, Main Menu -> Layer -> Export -> Color). Lustre recommends the best products at their lowest prices – right on Amazon. Substance painter has definitely a bad stroke control and blending, even in the last version. Also for things that need remotely Photoshop, as clothing and architecture Quixel is a lot better. Are the same results possible? most of my experience comes from dealing with versions 1.0 - 1.7 but i did a recent stint with a 2.x demo and found all my pet peeves were still in there. 3D coat has made UVing my work go super fast and it's actually quite fun because you're finished in a breeze. I'd love to put this feature to use, all I'm You can not use the brush to blend different strokes, the result is always look patchy, irregular and full of artifacts. The free trial is the only thing free. The most important reason people chose Substance Painter is: Since Substance Painter allows users to paint in full 3D, it can be used not only to paint full textures, but can also paint masks which can then be used in other tools (like Substance Designer) for material filter generators (like the ones used to make edge wear and dirt) Absolutely possible to get the same results, 3dcoat has better performance and a quicker setup but less features (for painting and shading). 3D Coat rates 4.3/5 stars with 20 reviews. Besides that it seems the one with best re topology tools. A lot of things I dislike about Painter, but I'm very hopeful for the future as they slowly seem to be addressing them. looking forward for the next upgrade ! Slant is powered by a community that helps you make informed decisions. I dislike the default lighting in the viewport at times; depending on the model, it can be hard to view certain faces with the default lighting/shading. 3d Coat is good but Substance Painter allows for more freedom for either realistic or stylized art styles. The features I use most are sculpting, retopology, and texture painting but there are more... i really like using substance painter for all alphas and brushes i can custom by myself.